I know books have not gone that far but it will be fine if answer can provide context from the books. Though Dayne declared that Rhaegar had ordered him to defend Lyanna Stark at the Tower of Joy, Ned and Howland saw them as traitors and cut them down. Why would she run away? Lord Reaver of Pyke was pretending he wasn't even there. Season 8. The speculation was that Rhaegar would rally the lords against the mad king in the tourney of Harrenhall. I think you've over dramatised the events, but yes, it was the call for the ward's heads which led to the rebellion. But even if they did, the real planning in my opinion still only would have started after the first round of executions, not the "abduction". 2022-03-29. It could have been that they received the word of executions from the same raven that brought the royal execution orders for Ned and Bobby B. Jon didn't feel threatened personally however, the Royal edict had nothing about Lord Arryn. Robert and Starks were not aware about this. Where did the Tyrells' loyalty lie during Robert's Rebellion? It's hard to think that this conversation NEVER took place. The details; how the "abduction" led to war -- is part of the "built on a" sub phrase. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts In the years preceding the outbreak of war, the actions of King Aerys II Targaryen had become increasingly erratic, believed by some to be . but of course, d&d forgot this because of their incredible bias towards targaryens. Reason why? ", Euler integration of the three-body problem, Field complete with respect to inequivalent absolute values. Earlier, it was believed that Prince Rhaegar, heir to the Iron Throne, kidnapped Lyanna, Ned's sister, who was engaged to Robert Baratheon. As Aegon describes, this is the likely because the singers sang a tale of love and loss, a more compelling song, then that of the defence of their own live. If so, anything between 36 hours and 10 minutes. And finally, a Targaryen alone in the world is a terrible thing. Article continues below advertisement. Only when Jon felt personally threatened and the deaths of the prisoners clear was there a real cause for rebellion. They however failed to play a much greater role for the loyalist Armies mostly because of the incompetence of Lord Tyrell and stubbornness of Stannis Baratheon. The Mad Kind had both of them killed in front of the entire Royal court, in his insanity; making Jon Arryn, the lord of the Eyrie, raise his banners in revolt against the crown and, sent Robert Baratheon and Ned back to their lands. Naming Lyanna Stark the Queen of Love and Beauty would spell death for Rhaegar, and war for the Seven Kingdoms. This point of view his held by most of Westeros as the reason for Robert's rebellion. Something can be "Built on a Lie" without there being deception or misdirection at the core. If they were unhappy, they would just talk to Lyanna, and not charge the Red Keep and ask for Rhaegar's head. Yeah fuck that, NSFW Thread, lets for Daenerys has a favorite and its not Drogon. But that doesn't answer why the other lords, aside from the Starks, followed him. I recently got in a discussion on this sub over whether Robert's Rebellion was based on a lie or not and I hear that all the time so I wanted to make a post arguing why it was absolutely not based on a lie. Robert is a salty, sulking bitch baby. There, Ned encountered the remaining men of the Kingsguard and their terrifying leader, Ser Arthur Dayne, the best swordsman in all of the Seven Kingdoms. "Robert's rebellion was built on a lie", Bran to Samwell Tarly - connecting the dots that finally confirms Jon is not just any bastard, but a Press J to jump to the feed. Months presumably? It lasted "close to a year" and resulted in the end of the Targaryen dynasty in the Seven Kingdoms and the beginning of Robert Baratheon's reign. Aerys was more of a symptom then a cause. During the hostile takeover of King's Landing, no Targaryen survived the mayhem. Did Lyanna Stark ever love Robert Baratheon? It was widely believed that Prince Rhaegar, heir to the Iron Throne, kidnapped Lyanna, Ned's sister who was betrothed to Robert Baratheon. Robert was betrothed to marry Lyanna Stark and it was . R&L added fuel to the fire of a rebellion. How actually can you perform the trick with the "illusion of the party distracting the dragon" like they did it in Vox Machina (animated series)? Following is a complete breakdown of their operations during the war: Battle of Ashford 2/10 Ned Stark Led The Army To King's Landing. Let's see what he can screw up Press J to jump to the feed. As Ned Stark remembers in A Song of Ice and Fire, this was the moment when all the smiles died" amid the concerned crowd. As Brandon was tied to a medieval hanging device, the Mad King placed a sword not far from his captive and offered an ultimatum: free yourself from the noose, and you may save your father. Tourney of Harrenhal happened in 281 AC in which Rhaegar crowned Lyanna as Queen of Love and Beauty. Everyone was just watching. ), Finally, we should probably not ignore the slow, subtle but determined involvement of the Citadel and perhaps house Hightower. Aerys did. Like with Helen of Troy, however, that elopement launched a thousand battles and forever altered the landscape of the Seven Kingdoms. Except most of that was revealed last season and book readers were talking about it in the fooking 90's. How do you feel about their relationship? Ned only came to know (If Lyanna told him all) only in the end of the war and others were never aware. This has not yet come to light fully in the books; but we've already learned from Marwyn that they was they had more than a hand in the Dance of the Dragons. They will rule together or Dany will die. It could be that they received the word from the same bird that brought the royal command for execution of the young Lords. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. In conclusion, therefore the "lie" the rebellion is based on is that Rhaegar kidnapped and raped Lyanna. Robert's Rebellion, also referred to as the War of the Usurper by Targaryen loyalists, was a major civil war in the history of the Seven Kingdoms of Westeros. Only for the famed Tourney at Harrenhal did Aerys finally venture out. The "lie" in question is usually cited to be Prince Rhaegar raping Lyanna Stark. It saw the ruling Targaryen dynasty displaced from power after 280 years by the Baratheon dynasty. Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Though he grew peeved when Tywin seemed to receive all the credit for his success, Aerys allowed the Lannister leader to continue his work uninterrupted (though on occasion he would drunkenly insult Tywin's wife, Joanna). The hostilities came to a head at the Battle of the Trident, where Rhaegar finally appeared in his ruby-studded armor. The argument is that based on the fact Lyanna probably didn't go against her will that the whole war was built on a lie. Vad gr man med sticklingar? At the time of coming to know about Bran's power of being a Third Eyed Raven, to which Sam's reaction was rather shocking and funny, leaving Bran no choice but to go back in time and have a reality check. Ironic that Rhaegar's son was named by Ned Stark to protect him, after the first person to raise the banners against the mad king. As the tradition allowed, the victor would then declare his Queen of Love and Beauty before the crowd. Although the rebellion only began with the call for the heads of the wards, there is no reason for us to think Robert didn't plea to be allowed to rise up against the king and claim back his betrothed, however after the death of Rickard, Brandon and their companions and the call for the death of the two wards was there real reason for a revolution. The Targaryen prince was dead, and Robert won his vengeance over Lyanna's captor. Language is defined by. Whether he intentionally perpetuated the rumor or accepted it as a result of his wounded pride, Robert Baratheon's famous rebellion was built on a lie. arryn refused, called his banners and the rebellion began. Aerys had them all killed (Except Ethan Glover). This is a wide open and minimally moderated subreddit to talk about the Game of Thrones/ASOIAF/HOTD episodes, spoilers, leaks, and books. "Built on a lie" is a set phrase that native speakers should be able to interpret as "built on a misunderstanding". A longtime Screen Rant contributor, Jared Canfield is an actor and writer based in New York City. Can it not be argued that Aerys' overreaction (killing Brandon) caused the rebellion? The captives and their fathers, all of them? The only think dany ever wanted was a family and she found it in jon. You can opt-out at any time by signing in to your account to manage your preferences. Lyanna's alleged kidnapping was the cause of the uproar of Robert's breakdown which ultimately led to his rebellion. So did Bran Stark actually go to demand Lyanna from Aerys and Rhaegar's punishment? Like the Olympics of the Seven Kingdoms, this ballyhooed jousting event attracted all the big names in Westeros. Robert's Rebellion, also known as the War of the Usurper, was a rebellion against House Targaryen, primarily instigated by Eddard Stark, Jon Arryn, and Robert Baratheon, for whom it is named. With the help of Tywin Lannister as his Hand of the King, he did a remarkable job of keeping the Seven Kingdoms safe and prosperous. Or at least Weeks? Were season 7 rules in force? If House of the Dragon spans 200 years, give or take, then it's possible. With all the prisoners executed, still no one lifted a finger. Aegon was also the name of Jon's older brother, who was brutally murdered by Ser Gregor 'The Mountain' Clegane during the Sack of King's Landing. As you can see, if Robert's Rebellion was indeed built on rescuing Lyanna, why didn't it break out as soon as Lyanna was abducted? Though it should have been a show of sportsmanship and honor, the Tourney set in motion the events that would lead to Robert's Rebellion. 2022-03-29 If the series should cover some past events in season 8, this definitely is one of the things that should be addressed in detail. From Summerhall to Storm's End and the Battle of the Bells, civil war flooded the land of Westeros. There he got himself imprisoned, the fool along with his friends Elbert Arryn, Jeffory Mallister, Kyle Royce and his squire Ethan Glover. Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? However we must note that we do not know how much time did pass between the execution of prisoners and Royal edict calling for deaths of Ned and Bobby B. Their allies feel honor bound not to betray their wards, refuse to give up their family, and raise their banners in refusal. Robert Baratheon was the firstborn son of Lord Steffon Baratheon and Lady Cassana Estermont. "Built on a Lie" is a saying in English that carries meaning beyond its component parts. rev2022.11.7.43013. With his proud father looking on, Rhaegar Targaryen was pronounced the champion jouster at Harrenhal. Knowing his actions would infuriate the houses in the north, Aerys also demanded the heads of Eddard Stark and Robert Baratheon. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Aegon Targaryen: The significance of Jon Snow's real name, {{ #verifyErrors }}{{ message }}{{ /verifyErrors }}{{ ^verifyErrors }}Something went wrong. After Brandon and Rickard were killed, Aerys asked for Eddard and Robert's heads. Though some of Jon Arynn and Robert's men stayed loyal to the throne, Robert tried to march north to meet with Jon. 2022-03-29. Though Brandon valiantly risked his life, he ultimately suffocated himself before he could keep his father from succumbing to the flames. Years before the series began, Robert was the Lord of the Storm's End and betrothed to Lyanna Stark, the only daughter of Lord Rickard Stark. @RichardC: Robert B would not have been happy, but he would have no leg to stand on. The Game of Thrones Wiki explains what went down after the "kidnapping": 'After Lyanna's abduction, her older brother Brandon, who had been on his way to Riverrun to wed Catelyn Tully, rode instead to King's Landing demanding that King Aerys II Targaryen, Rhaegar's father, have Lyanna returned and Rhaegar punished. Per my understanding it was not. It was never about Lyanna even though Robert personally wanted Lyanna more than he wanted a crown. Like with Helen of Troy, however, that elopement launched a thousand battles and forever altered the landscape of the Seven Kingdoms. I believe if/when he sits on the throne, Jon/Aegon will be the sixth of his name, since Aegon the unlikely, brother to Maester Aemon was fifth of his name. Why do the "<" and ">" characters seem to corrupt Windows folders? Game of Thrones Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. With her, Robert has three children: Joffrey, Myrcella, and Tommen . Not long after the tourney, word spread that Rhaegar had kidnapped Lyanna and disappeared with her. Bitter irony. That confession came after 2 episodes when Jon himself told Daenarys "your father burnt my grandfather and father alive" and conveniently Varys wasn't present in that discussion. By clicking Register you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to ourTerms of use,Cookie policyandPrivacy notice. How is it possible that your thoughts about Robert's Rebellion, F&B, Targaryens, Daenerys, Ned and Robert's friendship are exactly the same as mine. Robert could've wanted to rebel the entire time, but was held back by Jon. The captives and their fathers, all of them? If Aerys had merely denied Brandon's claim (which Aerys in fact could have. Fast forward to Robert's Rebellion and we get varying accounts of how and why Robert Baratheon became king of Westeros. And then demanded the heads of the rest of the conspirators? The only lie in the rebellion was Robert's belief about Lyanna's love for him. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, It was built on a lie, they just didnt know it, Maybe I'm repeating what @TheLethalCoder said, but "built on a lie" implies intentional lying, which isn't the case. Considering he already had produced multiple children with her, however, annulment apparently has a different meaning in Westeros than our own world. However, the Mad King, in his delusion and insanity, had them both put to death. Whether strategic or not, something did develop between Rhaegar and Lyanna very fast, almost as fast as Jon and Daenerys apparently (yes the hype is 20 years long but things develop very fast once they meet) and even if there is a plan, that is thrown away. HBO viewers guide, appendices, Robert's Rebellion entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Targaryen - Rhaegar Targaryen entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Baratheon of King's Landing - Robert Baratheon entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Targaryen - Aerys II Targaryen entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Arryn - Jon Arryn entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Baratheon of Dragonstone - Davos Seaworth entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Targaryen - Elia Targaryen entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Targaryen - Viserys Targaryen entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Targaryen - Rhaella Targaryen entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Baratheon of Dragonstone - Stannis Baratheon entry, Wars of the First Men and the Children of the Forest. It was an unexpected move from Prince Rhaegar, whose silvery hair and good looks made him a heartthrob to every woman in his wake. Though they cheered him on in his victory, they quickly grew silent at his show of affection for the woman who wasn't his wife. Had he stayed loyal to his first wife, Elia Martell, and their children, it's unlikely any conflict would have ever materialized. So Robert's Rebellion wasn't based on a lie. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Others eventually knew Lyanna went willingly. It is possible that (off-camera) someone who knew better lied, or someone expressed certainty beyond grounds and convinced them that this occurred. Though Lord Rickard obliged, Aerys labeled him a seditious leader upon his arrival at King's Landing. It's just that Bran has been fed the lies that it was to rescue Lyanna. How can the electric and magnetic fields be non-zero in the absence of sources? Robert's Rebellion, also known as the War of the Usurper, was one of the last great civil wars among the Great Houses of Westeros that took place approximately seventeen years before the War of the Five Kings begins, and lasted about one year; two, if one counts the Assault on Dragonstone as the final engagement of the conflict. Robert didn't start the war. @Annatar, indeed, there are many reasons to suspect that tourney of Harrenhal was actually an informal Great Council called to depose King Aerys , financed by either Tywin Lannister or Rhaegar himself. Killing Rhaegar at the Battle of . Allow Line Breaking Without Affecting Kerning. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. Of course there is the mad king being the mad king and executing the Starks, which causes all the chaos. The event was even more controversial as Rhaegar was thought to still be married to Elia Martell. Rhaegar, whom even George R. R. Martin describes as a love-struck prince, was equally besotted with Lyanna. We know that things didn't go according to plan once the mad king decided to attend the tourney, so things went south there. Viserys this, Robb Stark that. Please try again later{{ /verifyErrors }}, Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number, Please enter a name between 1 and 40 characters, You must be over 18 years old to register. In Season 7 Episode 7, The Dragon and the Wolf: When Bran goes in his vision to see Rhaegar and Lyanna getting married he mentions that Robert's rebellion was built on a lie. Robert Baratheon led the forces of the rebels and gave his name to the war on account of having the best blood claim to the Iron Throne. Movie News, Movie Trailers & upcoming Movie Reviews, The Leading Source for Gaming News, Reviews, and Interviews, That 90s Shows Cameos Secretly Confirm That 70s Point Place Problem, Game of Thrones: The Real History of Robert's Rebellion, Explained. When the Littlewood-Richardson rule gives only irreducibles? Aerys and Rhaegar didn't have the best relationship. What do you call an episode that is not closely related to the main plot? The Game of Thrones footage should excite any fan, as it involves Sansa Stark (Sophie Turner) meeting Daenerys Targaryen (Emilia Clarke) for the first time and ceding Winterfell (the Stark family home) to the Dragon Queen "Winterfell seu, sua senhoria", diz a mais velha das irms Stark Me dos Drages Dell T140 Nvme Sansa Stark has no. Sci-Fi Book With Cover Of A Person Driving A Ship Saying "Look Ma, No Hands! As for Rhaegar's father, Aerys wasn't always a bloodlust-filled lunatic. Brandon's treasonous acts: riding up to the Red Keep and asking for Rhaegar's head for stealing Lyanna. Did you expect HOTD to be successful? To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Neither did the honorable Lord Jon Arryn whose words were "As High as Honor". That Lyanna was abducted and raped. Though King Aerys deserved his title as the Mad King, it seems that his son, Rhaegar Targaryen, should bear a portion of the responsibility for driving Westeros into civil war. When Jon Arryn refused, he raised his banners, as well as those of Eddard (now Lord of Winterfell) and Robert in Rebellion. Robert's rebellion was it. @Flater I think you're being too pedantic in this case. The But Lone The Wolf Pack Dies Survives. Game of Thrones: When Will Season 8 Premiere? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Why didn't Ned Stark support this claim to the throne? This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the GooglePrivacy policyandTerms of serviceapply. The true story of Robert's Rebellion is finally being unearthed in Game Of Thrones - but is it too late to change anything in Westeros? This point of view his held by most of Westeros as the reason for Robert's rebellion. And third because it led the one honorable person in all of Westeros, Ned, to build a huge house of lies around the heritage of a young child, which at least had a part in his downfall years later. Game of Thrones, HBO. An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works The Targaryens were certainly not great at doing that, with their constant infighting (Blackfyre rebellions) and their psychological stability issues. Varys in S07E05 confesses to Tyrion that he was the one who told Aerys who the traitors were and Aerys punished them by burning them alive and Varys witnessed that. Or was it Aerys who demanded Bran's and Rickard's presence and burnt them as traitors? Robert was crowned king after King Aerys II Targaryen, his first cousin once removed, was killed during Robert's Rebellion. Instead, Jon Arryn rallied his bannermen and rose up in rebellion against the crown. Nobody raised any banners for Lyanna, nobody called their sworn swords. Liberation of Slaver's Bay. There are your Rebels, such as they are, the Glorious Honorable Lords who supposedly fought against the grave injustice done to Poor Robert Baratheon when bad Dragonprince stole away his Wolf-love. Notes: (See the end of the chapter for To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. The factor which actually started the war was Aerys' orders to have the young Lords Robert and Eddard executed. The reason they thought she must've been kidnapped was because she was betrothed to Robert. Robert's pride couldn't take the thought that his dream-girl would leave him.
Metaxa Private Reserve, Ellicott City Homes For Sale, Georgetown Medical School Ranking, Pasteurized Feta Pregnancy, Part Time Crisis Hotline Jobs, Html Helper Maxlength, Are Fireworks Legal In Pennsylvania,